Research/Snow and Ice Liability in Massachusetts
Snow and Ice Liability in Massachusetts
The standard Massachusetts courts apply when someone slips on snow or ice, how the appeals courts have used it since it changed in 2010, what 32 cities and towns require of the owners and occupants next to public sidewalks, and how often Boston tickets sidewalks left uncleared. Each rule traces to the court decision or municipal code it comes from.
Key findings
- In 2010 the Supreme Judicial Court ended the old split between “natural” and “unnatural” snow and ice. Property owners now owe lawful visitors the same reasonable care for snow and ice that they owe for any other hazard.
- In 2020 the court held that a tenant hurt by snow or ice in a common area brings a negligence claim against the landlord, and cannot recover injury damages under the warranty of habitability.
- Of the 32 cities and towns reviewed, 25 require the people next to a public sidewalk to clear it. Attleboro, Barnstable, Framingham, Hingham, Methuen, Milton and Weymouth have no general clearing rule.
- Most deadlines fall between three daylight hours, as in Boston and Waltham, and 24 hours, as in Revere, Springfield and Watertown. Where a path width is set, most require 36 or 42 inches; Worcester requires 4 feet.
- Six of the 25 apply their rule only to certain areas, buildings or storms: Brockton, Everett, Peabody, Plymouth, Quincy and Taunton.
- Boston issued 52,080 tickets for failing to clear a sidewalk of snow across the 14 winters from 2012–13 to 2025–26. The 2025–26 winter had 8,170, the most of any winter in the data.
Terms used on this page
- Natural and unnatural accumulation: the old rule. Snow and ice left as the weather made it was “natural,” and owners were generally not liable for it. Snow and ice that some human act had altered was “unnatural.”
- Reasonable care: what a reasonable person would do in the same situation, weighing how likely and how serious an injury is against the burden of preventing it.
- Lawful visitor: someone on the property with permission, such as a customer or guest.
- Abutter: the owner or occupant of property next to a public sidewalk or street.
- Common area: a part of a rental property that tenants share, such as a driveway, walkway or stairway.
- Comparative negligence: weighing the injured person’s own share of fault. A person found more than half responsible for their own injury cannot recover in negligence.
- Ordinance or by-law: a local law. Cities pass ordinances; towns pass by-laws.
- Published and unpublished decisions: published appellate decisions are binding precedent. Unpublished summary decisions of the Appeals Court are not, and can be cited only for their persuasive value.
Where this comes from
This page draws on three kinds of primary sources. The court rules come from the published opinions of the Supreme Judicial Court and the Appeals Court. The local rules come from each city’s or town’s own code, read on its official code site or in the PDF it publishes, and each is dated with the latest legislation the code says it includes. The Boston figures come from the city’s Public Works Violations dataset on Analyze Boston, the city’s open data site.
Every code section and court quotation was read in its original wording on October 6, 2026. The Boston counts were made by a script so the work can be checked.
Left out, and why:
- Unpublished Appeals Court summary decisions, because they are not binding. Two that bear on snow and ice are noted in the limits section.
- A 2018 Appeals Court decision on snow and ice notice whose publication status could not be confirmed.
- General Laws chapter 84, sections 17 and 21, which could not be read from the Legislature’s website on the retrieval date. The notice rule on this page comes from section 18, read from that site on September 23, 2026, and quoted in full by the Supreme Judicial Court in 2019.
- Fine amounts set by local ordinances.
- Boston citation records dated before December 2012. Boston says its dataset covers citations from December 2012 on.
Data windows
- Court decisions: 2010 through 2026, as found in the opinions reviewed.
- Local codes: each as current as the date shown in the table.
- Boston citations: winters 2012–13 through 2025–26.
- All sources read October 6, 2026.
The 2010 decision that set one duty for all snow and ice
Before 2010, Massachusetts treated snow and ice differently from other hazards. An owner could generally be held liable only for an “unnatural” accumulation, one that some human act had altered, and not for snow or ice left as the weather made it. In Papadopoulos v. Target Corp., 457 Mass. 368 (2010), the Supreme Judicial Court ended that split. It held that owners owe lawful visitors the same duty of reasonable care for snow and ice as for every other hazard on their property.
The court described that duty as acting reasonably in light of all the circumstances: how likely an injury is, how serious it could be, and the burden of reducing the risk. It also set limits. The duty “does not make a property owner an insurer” of its property, and what counts as reasonable snow removal can differ for a single-family home, an apartment building, a store and a nursing home.
Three other points from the decision:
- The court wrote that it is not reasonable to leave snow or ice on a walkway when a visitor can be expected to cross it anyway.
- The new rule applied to pending cases, not only future ones. One reason the court gave was that state sanitary, fire and building regulations had long required most owners to keep entrances and exits clear of snow and ice.
- The decision covered snow and ice on private property. A footnote described the separate rule for public sidewalks as a different legal track that the case did not decide.
Since 2010: what the appeals courts have decided
The table lists the published decisions found that apply the 2010 rule to snow and ice, or that settle a question it left open. It is not a complete list of every case.
| Decision | Court and year | What it held |
|---|---|---|
| Papadopoulos v. Target Corp., 457 Mass. 368 | Supreme Judicial Court, 2010 | Ended the natural and unnatural accumulation rule. Owners owe lawful visitors reasonable care for all snow and ice. |
| Lindor v. McDonald’s Restaurants of Massachusetts, Inc., 80 Mass. App. Ct. 909 | Appeals Court, 2011 | The new rule applied to a fall near a restaurant entrance because no final judgment had been entered when Papadopoulos was decided. Whether the restaurant knew of the ice and acted reasonably was a question for trial. |
| Halbach v. Normandy Real Estate Partners, 90 Mass. App. Ct. 669 | Appeals Court, 2016 | An owner next to a public way must not create an unsafe condition there, “but no more.” Papadopoulos did not apply. The case involved uneven pavement, not snow. |
| Meyer v. Veolia Energy North America, 482 Mass. 208 | Supreme Judicial Court, 2019 | Quoted the public-way notice statute in full, including its rule for snow and ice injuries. The case itself involved a utility cover, not snow. |
| Goreham v. Martins, 485 Mass. 54 | Supreme Judicial Court, 2020 | A tenant hurt on snow or ice in a common area may sue the landlord in negligence. Injury damages are not available under the warranty of habitability. |
Sources: the published opinions, read in full text on October 6, 2026.
Goreham involved a tenant who fell on ice in the driveway of a three-family house. The jury found the landlords negligent, but found the tenant more than half at fault, so the negligence claim failed under comparative negligence. The court confirmed that, after Papadopoulos, a negligence claim is the route for these injuries, and it declined to stretch the warranty of habitability to cover them. It also held that comparative negligence does not apply to a separate tenant claim under the quiet enjoyment statute, but found that a temporarily icy driveway was not the kind of serious interference that claim requires.
Public sidewalks follow a separate rule
In Papadopoulos, the Supreme Judicial Court described the older rule for public sidewalks in a footnote, quoting a 1938 decision: an owner or occupant next to a public way has no obligation to keep the sidewalk free of snow or ice that came there from natural causes. The court called this “a third legal track” and did not decide it.
In 2016, in Halbach, the Appeals Court restated the abutter’s duty on a public way as a duty not to create an unsafe condition there. That case involved pavement, not snow. A concurring judge wrote that whether to change the rule is a question for the Supreme Judicial Court. No published decision found since then has changed it.
Local ordinances are a separate matter. Most of the cities and towns reviewed below require abutters to clear public sidewalks and enforce that requirement with fines. None of the decisions reviewed here addresses whether breaking such an ordinance makes an owner liable to someone who falls.
Notice after a fall on a public way
Massachusetts law asks someone hurt by a defect in a public way to give written notice within 30 days to the county, city, town or person responsible for keeping the way in repair, stating the time, place and cause of the injury. For injuries caused by snow or ice, the statute adds that a failure to give notice is not a defense unless the defendant proves it was prejudiced by it. The Supreme Judicial Court quoted that language in full in 2019.
The notice rules, filing deadlines and the separate process for claims against public employers are covered on our page on Massachusetts injury claim deadlines and notice requirements.
What 32 cities and towns require at the sidewalk
Of the 32 cities and towns reviewed, 25 require the owner, occupant or both to clear the public sidewalk next to their property. Most set a deadline in hours after the snow stops and a minimum path width. Six narrow the rule to certain places, buildings or storms. Each row gives the code section and the latest legislation the code says it includes.
| Community | Who must clear | Deadline | Path to clear | Where it applies | Code section, current through |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Boston | Owner or manager; a tenant if a written lease requires it | 3 hours after snow stops, counting hours between sunrise and sunset | 42 inches; curb ramps also covered | All abutting property | City Code § 16-12.16; current through Ord. 2025 c. 14, Nov. 5, 2025 |
| Brockton | Owner, occupant or tenant | 8 hours after each snowfall | Not stated; includes ramps and curb cuts | Downtown area only, inside listed boundary streets | Rev. Ords. § 20-14; through July 31, 2025 |
| Brookline | Owner or agent | 3 daylight hours in business and industrial districts and buildings with more than 4 units; 24 hours for others (30 if the storm ends Friday 4 p.m. to Saturday noon) | 36 inches; curb ramps and driveway crossings included | All abutting land, in tiers | General By-laws Art. 7.7; through Nov. 18, 2025 |
| Cambridge | Owner or occupant | 12 hours after daytime snow; by 1 p.m. after overnight snow; ice within 6 hours | Not stated | All private property beside a sidewalk | Municipal Code § 12.16.110; through Ord. 2025-8, Apr. 7, 2025 |
| Chelsea | Owner, agent or person in charge | 24 hours after snow stops | Not stated | All property beside a sidewalk | Code § 24-21; through Oct. 20, 2025 |
| Everett | Owner | 12 hours after a declared snow emergency or the snowfall ends | 36 inches or about two-thirds of the width, whichever is less | Declared snow emergencies only; all properties, including public and nonprofit | Rev. Ords. § 17-6A; through June 23, 2025 |
| Fall River | Owner or tenant | No more than 5 hours, counting hours between sunrise and sunset | Not stated; wheelchair ramps included | All property beside a sidewalk | Code § 66-32; through Dec. 23, 2025 |
| Haverhill | Tenant or occupant; owner or agent if none | 6 hours; not in force 9 p.m. to 9 a.m. | Not stated; 4 feet where no sidewalk is laid out | All property beside a sidewalk | Code ch. 216; through June 30, 2026 |
| Lawrence | Owner | 24 hours after snow stops | 36 inches; curb ramps included | All property beside a sidewalk | Municipal Code § 12.04.040; through June 7, 2022 |
| Lowell | Owner, agent or person in charge | 12 hours; by 1 p.m. the next day if snow stops after 6 p.m. | Not stated; access from the street required | All property beside a public way, including private alleys | Code § 243-3; through July 14, 2026 |
| Lynn | Owner, manager or tenant | 3 hours between sunrise and sunset for commercial, mixed-use and buildings over 6 units; 10 hours for buildings of 6 units or fewer | Full paved path or 42 inches; curb cuts, crosswalks and ramps included | All property, in two tiers | 2015 amendment, City Council, Mar. 10, 2015; Lynn’s ordinances are not compiled online |
| Malden | Owner, occupant or agent | 24 hours, or 12 for commercial and multifamily of 5 or more units, after snow ends or the city declares cleanup complete | At least 36 inches | All property, in two tiers | Code § 11.08.130; latest amendment Feb. 11, 2020; no compiled-through date shown |
| Medford | Owner, tenant, occupant or agent | 8 daylight hours after snow stops or a snow emergency ends | 36 inches; crossing entrances and 36 inches around hydrants | All property beside a sidewalk | Rev. Ords. § 74-114; version of Oct. 8, 2025 |
| New Bedford | Owner or occupant | A “reasonable time”; in unusual conditions 4 hours after daytime snow or by 11 a.m. after overnight snow | Not stated | All property beside a sidewalk | Code § 22-15; version of May 18, 2026 |
| Newton | Owner or occupant | 12 hours in business, mixed-use and manufacturing districts and for commercial, institutional or 5-plus-unit buildings; 24 hours for others | Whole sidewalk and curb ramps for the first group; about 36 inches and ramps for others | All property, in two tiers | Rev. Ords. §§ 26-8, 26-8D; city PDF updated Apr. 6, 2022 |
| Peabody | Owner, tenant or occupant | 4 hours after daytime snow; by 10 a.m. after overnight snow | Whole sidewalk | Peabody Square and listed streets only | Code §§ 27-71 to 27-73; version of July 7, 2026 |
| Plymouth | Owner or agent | 24 hours for a passable path; 6 daylight hours on paved sidewalks | A passable path; no more than an inch left on paved sidewalks | Within one mile of the shoreline, Jabez Corner to the Kingston line | Code § 270-6; through May 21, 2026 |
| Quincy | Owner, tenant and occupant | 5 hours after daytime snow; by 1 p.m. after overnight snow; ice within 5 hours | Not stated | Buildings with any nonresidential use only | Code § 305-24; through Oct. 6, 2025 |
| Revere | Owner; cannot be shifted to a tenant by lease | 24 hours after snow stops; ice within 24 hours | 36 inches; ramps and curb cuts included | All property; owner-occupants 65 or older or disabled are exempt from enforcement | Rev. Ords. §§ 12.04.350 to .354; through Ord. C.O. 26-155, Aug. 10, 2026 |
| Somerville | Person in charge, including owner, occupant, tenant or agent | 6 hours between sunrise and sunset after the storm ends | 36 inches; commercial buildings must also clear an adjoining curb ramp | All property beside a sidewalk | Code § 12-8; version effective Dec. 11, 2025 |
| Springfield | Tenant or occupant of a one-unit parcel; otherwise owner or person in charge | 24 hours after snow stops | Not stated; sidewalk, fire hydrant and curb cut | All property beside a street with a sidewalk, hydrant or curb cut | Code § 322-1; through Dec. 15, 2025 |
| Taunton | Owner | 4 hours after daytime snow; by 11 a.m. after overnight snow; ice within 24 hours | Entire width | Business, central business and highway business districts only | Code § 383-15; through Sept. 22, 2025 |
| Waltham | Owner or agent | Within the first 3 hours between sunrise and sunset | 36 inches | All property except single- and two-family homes | Code § 17-23; through Jan. 12, 2026 |
| Watertown | Owner | 24 hours after snow, sleet or freezing rain stops | 42 inches, or the full width if narrower; access at curb cuts and ramps | All property beside a sidewalk | Code § 96.26; through Aug. 11, 2026 |
| Worcester | Owner or occupant | 10 hours after a winter storm | 4 feet; paths to crosswalks and crossing buttons | All property beside a sidewalk, including on state highways | Rev. Ords. ch. 12 § 23; amended through Sept. 8, 2026 |
Read on each community’s official code site or published code on October 6, 2026. Lawrence’s online code includes legislation only through June 2022, Newton’s chapter PDF is dated April 2022, and Lynn’s text is a 2015 amendment, so later changes may not appear. Most of these communities also have rules about moving snow into the street; the details differ.
The other seven have no general rule requiring owners or occupants to clear public sidewalks. Most still regulate where snow can be put.
| Community | What the code does say | Code reviewed, current through |
|---|---|---|
| Attleboro | Its sidewalk snow removal section was deleted in 1999. It bars placing snow on public sidewalks and streets. | Rev. Ords. § 11-10; through Oct. 21, 2025 |
| Barnstable | Bars placing snow on a street or sidewalk without permission. | Code ch. 206, Art. II; through Mar. 26, 2026 |
| Framingham | Requires clearing only at accessible parking spaces and their sidewalks and curb cuts: by 10 p.m. after daytime snow, 10 a.m. after overnight snow. | Code § 343-3; through July 21, 2026 |
| Hingham | Requires snow guards on roofs that slope toward a sidewalk; no clearing rule. | General By-laws; revised through 2025 Annual Town Meeting |
| Methuen | Bars placing snow in the street, except sidewalk snow at the curb edge. | Code § 9-51; code PDF dated Feb. 5, 2025 |
| Milton | Bars placing snow on a public way in a way that obstructs traffic. | General Bylaws § 230-4; through June 16, 2025 |
| Weymouth | Bars depositing snow so it obstructs a public way or sidewalk. The town code assigns snow and ice removal on public sidewalks to the Highway Division. | Code §§ 8-406(d), 4-207(d)(1); through Feb. 17, 2026 |
Each code was searched in full for snow and ice provisions on October 6, 2026.
How often Boston tickets an uncleared sidewalk
Boston’s Public Works Department issues tickets under the sidewalk snow ordinance, and the city publishes the citations in its Public Works Violations dataset. Across the 14 winters from 2012–13 to 2025–26, it issued 52,080 tickets for failing to clear a sidewalk of snow, an average of about 3,720 a winter. The count swings widely: 1,045 in 2022–23, the fewest, and 8,170 in 2025–26, the most. The last two winters account for 29.2% of all tickets in the period.
In 2025–26, 75.7% of the tickets went to residential property and 24.3% to nonresidential property. The city also issued 2,300 tickets over the same winters for moving snow from private property onto a sidewalk or street.
| Winter | Failure to clear sidewalk | Residential, 16 units or fewer | Residential, more than 16 units | Nonresidential | Snow moved onto sidewalk or street |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2012–13 | 2,970 | 2,271 | 84 | 615 | 378 |
| 2013–14 | 1,923 | 1,548 | 47 | 328 | 197 |
| 2014–15 | 5,766 | 4,186 | 486 | 1,094 | 411 |
| 2015–16 | 3,917 | 3,248 | 150 | 519 | 198 |
| 2016–17 | 3,581 | 2,766 | 205 | 610 | 153 |
| 2017–18 | 4,993 | 4,060 | 199 | 734 | 120 |
| 2018–19 | 1,856 | 1,563 | 40 | 253 | 153 |
| 2019–20 | 2,353 | 1,856 | 26 | 471 | 15 |
| 2020–21 | 3,477 | 2,555 | 124 | 798 | 283 |
| 2021–22 | 3,383 | 2,633 | 64 | 686 | 82 |
| 2022–23 | 1,045 | 900 | 28 | 117 | 12 |
| 2023–24 | 1,587 | 1,290 | 46 | 251 | 4 |
| 2024–25 | 7,059 | 5,565 | 166 | 1,328 | 70 |
| 2025–26 | 8,170 | 5,817 | 364 | 1,989 | 224 |
| Total | 52,080 | 40,258 | 2,029 | 9,793 | 2,300 |
A winter runs July 1 to June 30. Each ticket is counted once and placed in a winter by the date in the dataset’s status field, the only date the dataset provides. Violation codes 17A, 17B and 17C (failure to clear) and 15A to 16B (moving snow), as defined in the city’s data dictionary. Source: City of Boston, Public Works Violations, Analyze Boston, retrieved October 6, 2026.
Over the last five winters, 2021–22 to 2025–26, Dorchester received the most failure-to-clear tickets, followed by South Boston and Brighton. These are counts of tickets, not rates. Neighborhoods differ in size, housing and sidewalk length.
| Neighborhood | Tickets | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Dorchester | 3,883 | 18.3% |
| South Boston | 2,574 | 12.1% |
| Brighton | 2,272 | 10.7% |
| Boston | 2,150 | 10.1% |
| Jamaica Plain | 1,783 | 8.4% |
| Roxbury | 1,647 | 7.8% |
| East Boston | 1,523 | 7.2% |
| Allston | 1,088 | 5.1% |
| Roslindale | 989 | 4.7% |
| West Roxbury | 789 | 3.7% |
| Charlestown | 738 | 3.5% |
| Mattapan | 737 | 3.5% |
| Hyde Park | 624 | 2.9% |
| Mission Hill | 443 | 2.1% |
| Other labels* | 4 | under 0.1% |
| Total | 21,244 | 100% |
Neighborhood is the place name the dataset gives for the violation address. “Boston” is the dataset’s own label. *Chestnut Hill (3) and Dorchester Center (1). Source: City of Boston, Public Works Violations, Analyze Boston, retrieved October 6, 2026.
What this page does not settle
- Who was at fault in any fall. These are rules and counts, not findings about any property.
- Every appellate decision on snow and ice. The decisions listed are the published ones found; others may exist.
- Unpublished decisions. Two recent Appeals Court summary decisions touch on snow and ice: one about a city parking lot and governmental immunity (2024), and one about a tenant that had taken over snow and ice maintenance from its landlord (2026). They are not binding.
- Rules for private ways, condominium documents, leases or state property, which can set their own duties.
- Whether a ticket was upheld. The Boston dataset records tickets and their status, not the outcome of any appeal.
- The exact issue date of each Boston ticket. The dataset’s only date is a status date, which may change after a ticket is issued.
- Amendments adopted after the date shown for each local code.
Applying this to a particular fall
The rules above describe the framework. Whether a claim may exist after a specific fall depends on where it happened, who owned or controlled that spot, what that person knew and did about the snow or ice, and whether any notice deadline applies. A public sidewalk, a store’s parking lot and a rental property’s driveway can each lead to a different analysis.
Citing this page
Larson Law Boston, “Snow and Ice Liability in Massachusetts,” published October 6, 2026. Court decisions 2010 to 2026; local codes as dated in each table row; Boston citations winters 2012–13 to 2025–26. Sources read October 6, 2026.
The tables on this page may be reproduced with attribution and a link to this page. Press and research inquiries: marketing@dlarsonlaw.com
Sources
- Supreme Judicial Court, Papadopoulos v. Target Corp., 457 Mass. 368 (2010) (Caselaw Access Project copy; official page: https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2483064/papadopoulos-v-target-corporation/). Read October 6, 2026.
- Appeals Court, Lindor v. McDonald’s Restaurants of Massachusetts, Inc., 80 Mass. App. Ct. 909 (2011) (Caselaw Access Project copy; official page: https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/6589688/x/). Read October 6, 2026.
- Appeals Court, Halbach v. Normandy Real Estate Partners, 90 Mass. App. Ct. 669 (2016) (Caselaw Access Project copy; official page: https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/4322618/x/). Read October 6, 2026.
- Supreme Judicial Court, Meyer v. Veolia Energy North America, 482 Mass. 208 (2019) (archived copy; official page: https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/4617953/x/). Read October 6, 2026.
- Supreme Judicial Court, Goreham v. Martins, 485 Mass. 54 (2020), slip opinion SJC-12761. Read October 6, 2026.
- Massachusetts Legislature, General Laws c. 84, § 18 (archived copy; official page: https://malegislature.gov/Laws/GeneralLaws/PartI/TitleXIV/Chapter84/Section18). Read September 23, 2026.
- City of Boston, Public Works Violations dataset and data dictionary, Analyze Boston (archived copy; official page: https://data.boston.gov/dataset/public-works-violations). Retrieved October 6, 2026.
- City of Boston, City of Boston Code § 16-12.16 (the city’s rules page, which cites this section; official code page: https://codelibrary.amlegal.com/codes/boston/latest/boston_ma/0-0-0-11205). Read October 6, 2026.
- Municipal codes on eCode360, Barnstable, Brookline, Everett, Fall River, Framingham, Haverhill, Lowell, Milton, Plymouth, Quincy, Revere, Springfield, Taunton, Waltham, Watertown and Weymouth codes. Sections as cited in the tables. Read October 6, 2026.
- Municipal codes on Municode, Brockton, Cambridge, Chelsea, Lawrence, Medford, New Bedford and Peabody codes (archived copy; official page: https://library.municode.com/ma). Sections as cited in the tables. Read October 6, 2026.
- City of Somerville, Code of Ordinances § 12-8. Read October 6, 2026.
- City of Malden, Municipal Code § 11.08.130. Read October 6, 2026.
- City of Worcester, Revised Ordinances of 2008, ch. 12, § 23. Read October 6, 2026.
- City of Newton, Revised Ordinances ch. 26 (archived copy; official page: https://www.newtonma.gov/home/showpublisheddocument/29815/637867564630830000). Read October 6, 2026.
- City of Lynn, 2015 ordinance amending snow removal, City Ordinance Code page. Read October 6, 2026.
- City of Attleboro, Revised Ordinances (archived copy; official page: https://www.cityofattleboro.us/DocumentCenter/View/323/City-Ordinances-PDF). Read October 6, 2026.
- City of Methuen, Municipal Code (archived copy; official page: https://www.methuen.gov/DocumentCenter/View/3965/City-of-Methuen-Municipal-Code-PDF). Read October 6, 2026.
- Town of Hingham, General By-Laws (archived copy; official page: https://www.hingham-ma.gov/DocumentCenter/View/2464). Read October 6, 2026.
If you were hurt and have questions
These pages explain what the public record shows. They are not advice about a specific situation, and what applies to a particular case depends on its facts. If something here raises a question about your own circumstances, you are welcome to get in touch.
